Row Margaux: Polished Leather vs. Matte Grained

A Closer Look at the Style and Personality of Each Finish

If you’re debating between the polished or matte grained version of a Margaux bag, you are not alone. The silhouette is unmistakably elegant either way, but the leather finish completely changes how the bag looks and behaves in the real world.

The difference between finishes isn’t the leather quality (both use calfskin), but the surface treatment—the final step that determines texture, sheen, durability, and long-term personality.

Here is how the two compare using the Margaux Shoulder 12 as our muse.

Front view comparison of the polished vs. grained leather finishes of the Margaux Shoulder 12

Matte Grained Calfskin: The Everyday Classic

A Textured, Durable, Low-Maintenance Finish

The Row Margaux Shoulder 12

Color: Deep Brown | Material: Matte Grained Calfskin Leather with Silver Hardware

14.75 x 9 x 5 in. with a ~10 in. handle drop

The matte grained version has a pebbled, tactile surface that gives the bag a relaxed-elegant feel. The grain naturally disguises scratches, scuffs and signs of wear, making it the more forgiving and practical choice for everyday use. The grained texture adds dimension, giving the silhouette structure without feeling too formal or stiff. Some note that the grained leather is thinner or less premium than the polished version—but I don’t share that view. The two finishes naturally differ in weight and feel, but The Row’s grained leather is still undeniably high-quality: soft, flexible, and impressively durable, with a refined texture that holds up beautifully with daily wear.

Commuting, errands, travel, humidity — this finish tends to handle it all gracefully. It also ages beautifully, developing soft character without showing obvious flaws. It maintains structure while still being flexible. Overall it is a lower maintenance leather that does not need to be babied and maintains its look over time.

The bag features four protective feet, a zippered pocket, two card slots, and an open interior secured by a toggle closure for practical, everyday use. Unlike many of the current grained Margaux models which are lined in canvas, the Shoulder 12 is fully lined in lambskin, an indulgent detail you notice every time you reach inside.

Stylistically, the matte grained leather pairs beautifully with denim, knits, tailored suits, and elevated basics. It transitions easily from weekday to weekend and feels quietly polished without being to formal.

Who This Finish Is For

• You want a daily-use luxury bag

• You prefer low maintenance

• You love a mix of elevated + casual style

• You want a bag that ages quietly and gracefully

Polished Calfskin: The Refined Minimalist

A Sleek, Architectural, Elevated Look

The Row Margaux Shoulder 12

Color: Burgundy Brown | Material: Polished Saddle Leather with Silver Hardware

14.75 x 9 x 5 in. with a ~10 in. handle drop

The polished (smooth) calfskin version is a different personality entirely. Without texture to break up the surface, the clean lines of the bag take center stage, creating a silhouette that becomes more sculptural and refined. This is a more formal and intentional look that is strikingly gorgeous with colors that tend to be richer, deeper, and smoother. However, smooth leather is naturally more delicate. Scratches, scuffs, or water marks are more noticeable, and this finish generally requires a bit more attention in both use and storage.

In addition to the standard dust bag, The Row includes an extra protective cover specifically for the polished leather versions for added safeguarding during storage. Within the first hour of wearing my brand-new beauty, there were light scuffs around the bag. I expected it, embraced it, and reminded myself that this is a bag meant to be lived in. A little leather conditioner and a soft cloth softened the marks, making them almost invisible. Over time, those subtle marks soften into a rich, luxurious patina that feels effortlessly elegant—like something thoughtfully collected, well-loved, and uniquely yours.

1. Protective cover included with polished leather versions. 2. Light scuffs after initial wear. 3. Same area after a quick leather-conditioner treatment.

The weight difference between these two versions is minimal, but the polished leather version feels heavier and more substantial because of its dense, sleek finish. It also holds its structure exceptionally well over time—remaining firm and architectural—yet it is surprisingly soft and pliable and does not feel too rigid. If you love the crisp, sculpted silhouette the Margaux is known for, the polished versions are the ones that maintain that clean shape the longest. The polished leather Margaux bags are typically more expensive, harder to find directly from The Row, and they often command higher prices on the resale market.

Similar to the grained version, the polished leather Margaux also features four protective feet, a zippered pocket, two card slots, an open interior secured by a toggle closure, and is fully lined in lambskin.

In styling, polished calfskin is ideal for minimal wardrobes and “quiet luxury” aesthetics. Think tonal dressing, sharp outerwear, long coats, simple knits, and tailored trousers. It’s the finish you reach for when you want your bag to look truly refined.

Who This Finish Is For

• You love a sculptural, clean aesthetic

• Your wardrobe leans tailored, polished, refined

• You don’t mind scuffs and a little extra care

• You don’t mind a higher price tag

Side view comparison of the polished vs. grained leather finishes of the Margaux Shoulder 12

Which Finish Is Right for You?

Both finishes are luxurious and classic, but they serve different lifestyles:

• Choose Matte Grained if you want a durable, low-maintenance, everyday companion.

• Choose Polished if you want something sleek, intentional, sculptural—and you’re willing to give it a little extra care.

Ultimately, the best finish is the one that aligns with your wardrobe, your routines, and the mood you want the bag to bring to your day. Both versions are elegant and stay true to The Row’s minimalist ethos, yet each interprets it a little differently. In my view, both finishes can coexist beautifully in a wardrobe—offering the same timeless silhouette with two distinct personalities that keep the Margaux feeling fresh.

Read more in our Margaux Guide comparing the 10 vs 12 vs Shoulder 12 vs 15, and more on the Shoulder 12 in our Margaux 10 vs Shoulder 12 Comparison.

This website contains affiliate links. If you click a link and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely love.