The Row Agnes 12: Nubuck vs Grained Leather Review
Comparing texture, structure, durability, and wear over time
The Agnes is becoming one of The Row’s defining silhouettes, turning a scrunched construction into something polished, controlled, and unexpectedly elegant. The design is driven by folds, cinching, and broad uninterrupted panels which makes leather choice have a pronounced effect on both its visual character and tactile appeal.
This review takes a closer look at the Agnes 12 in grained and nubuck calfskin, focusing on how each leather changes the bag’s structure, feel, visual presence, and everyday performance.
For a closer look at the silhouette itself, see our Agnes 12 Review.
The Row Agnes 12 in Grained vs Nubuck Calfskin — Front View Comparison
At a Glance
Both finishes are designed to be worn and enjoyed, but they differ in visual texture and how the leather develops character over time.
| Grained Calfskin | Nubuck Calfskin | |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Design-forward everyday carry | A more refined interpretation |
| Finish | Slightly shiny and grained | Matte and grained |
| Feel | Soft, squishy, and pliant | Soft and velvety |
| Look | Light-catching and immediately expressive | More muted, tactile, and controlled |
| Shape | Slouchier from the outset, with a more collapsed feel | Holds its shape better while still preserving the folds |
| Presence | Expressive | Refined |
| Wear | More forgiving in day-to-day use | Durable but more delicate in daily wear |
| Care | Lower-maintenance, can show scratching | Requires more caution and upkeep |
| Price | $4,100 | $4,300 |
Where to Buy the Row Agnes Bag
The Agnes is becoming one of the Row’s most recognizable silhouettes and has appeared in multiple finishes across recent seasons. It is typically available through the brand’s boutiques, official website, and select luxury retailers. It tends to sell through quickly, with pieces not yet as readily available on the resale market.
Current sourcing options:
The Row — Official online store
Mytheresa — Authorized luxury retailer
Fashionphile— Resale marketplace
The Row Agnes 12 in grained calfskin in Hippo Grey, highlighting the leather’s slight shine, soft grain, and the bag’s naturally slouchy, squished character.
Texture and Structure
On the Agnes 12, leather choice changes the silhouette as much as the surface.
Grained calfskin makes the Agnes feel more pliant from the outset. The leather’s softness and slight shine give the folds a natural ease, while the broader panels catch light in a way that makes the shape feel richer and more immediately expressive. The grained calfskin leans into the bag’s naturally softened character and scrunched construction.
Nubuck calfskin shifts the emphasis toward line and construction. Its matte, velvety finish quiets the surface, so the silhouette feels less glossy and more defined by its lines. While still soft, nubuck holds the shape with more discipline, giving the Agnes a more composed presence. The folds remain central to the design, but the panels and overall shape appear cleaner and more intentional. The nubuck reads less as slouch and more as design.
Both versions are lined in soft lambskin, which adds another layer of tactile indulgence to the bag.
The Row Agnes 12 in nubuck calfskin in Nuez, highlighting the velvety texture and quieter, more refined expression of the silhouette.
Appearance & Style
Leather choice also meaningfully shifts the style of the Agnes.
In grained calfskin, the Agnes has more casual ease while still remaining polished. The slight shine gives the surface more movement, making the bag feel more approachable, and slightly less controlled. The folds feel especially natural here, reinforcing the bag’s softer, squishier character.
In nubuck calfskin, the Agnes reads quieter and more luxurious. The matte, velvety finish subdues the surface and gives the shape a calmer, more refined presence. The folds remain integral to the design, but they feel more intentional and more resolved.
Both versions integrate easily into casual and dressier wardrobes and feel wearable across seasons, especially in grounded shades like Hippo Grey and Nuez. Hippo Grey reads less as a strict cool grey and more as a softened brown-grey neutral, which gives it broad versatility throughout the year. Nuez reads as a light-to-medium brown with a rich velvety texture that also works well year-round, especially with both tailored and casual dressing.
The difference is less about versatility and more about expression: grained calfskin brings out the Agnes’s softer, slouchier character, while nubuck gives it a quieter, more elevated, and more distinctive presence.
Durability & Wear
Both leathers are durable, but they wear differently over time.
Grained calfskin is the easier of the two in daily use. Its texture helps soften the appearance of minor scratches and everyday handling, and the leather’s natural softness enhances the Agnes’s scrunched construction from the outset. The shiny grained finish is still a bit less forgiving than the matte grained leather used on the Margaux, but it remains the more practical option overall.
Nubuck calfskin requires a bit more care. The velvety matte surface is central to its appeal, but it also tends to show wear more readily from friction, handling, and exposure. While the leather feels substantial, the finish makes it the more delicate day-to-day option.
In practice, grained calfskin is the easier choice for regular rotation, while nubuck is better suited for those comfortable with a bit more care.
Maintenance
Both finishes use high-quality leather and are designed for regular use, but they differ in the level of care they benefit from.
Grained calfskin requires very little upkeep. Occasional conditioning and proper storage are typically sufficient. This shinier grained finish is still a bit less forgiving than the matte grained leather and benefits from awareness around surface contact and scratching. It is also the more practical choice in wetter climates, where the leather is less sensitive to moisture exposure in day-to-day use.
Nubuck calfskin benefits from more attentive care due to the natural treatment of the leather. Its matte, velvety surface is more sensitive to friction, moisture, and general contact, and it may show marking more readily over time. If needed, it can be cleaned by gently wiping with a soft, damp cloth and drying immediately. Direct heat, as well as any solvents and liquids containing alcohol, should be avoided.
For both versions, proper storage helps preserve the shape. When not in use, lightly stuffing the interior with tissue or a soft insert helps the bag hold its form, while storing it in its provided dust bag protects the leather from dust and light exposure while still allowing the material to breathe.
A closer look at the Row Agnes 12 in grained vs nubuck calfskin, highlighting the side profile, top view of the zipper, and lambskin-lined interior.
Longevity & Relevance
The Agnes has the kind of distinct yet refined shape that moves it beyond trend and into core silhouette. More unconventional than many of the brand’s day bags, it still feels controlled and resolved rather than directional.
Its identity comes down to proportion, construction, and material quality, all of which support its longevity. The sculptural shape may appear unusual at first, but it remains restrained enough to wear easily over time.
What makes the Agnes especially compelling is that its slightly compressed, almost squished quality still reads elegant. In either finish, this bag will maintain visual interest over time. That tension is difficult to achieve, and part of what gives the bag its lasting appeal.
The Row Agnes 12 in grained and nubuck calfskin, comparing how leather choice changes the silhouette, structure, and overall expression of the bag.
Choose Grained Calfskin if:
You want a softer, more casual expression
You prefer a shinier, more visibly grained surface
You like leather that feels squishy and pliant from the outset
You want a lower maintenance and more practical option for frequent use
Choose Nubuck Calfskin if:
You want a quieter, more refined interpretation
You prefer a matte finish with a soft, velvety hand
You want more structure while still preserving the folds
You are comfortable with a bit more care and surface sensitivity
Final Take
The Agnes 12 shifts meaningfully with leather choice.
In grained calfskin, it feels softer, slouchier, and easier — the better choice for someone especially drawn to the bag’s squished character and wanting that relaxed effect to come through more fully. It is also the more practical option for everyday use, especially in wetter climates where nubuck’s velvety surface requires more caution.
Nubuck takes the same silhouette in a more elevated direction. The leather feels soft but more structured, allowing the bag to hold its shape more fully. The velvety finish gives it a striking but muted presence, making the Agnes feel quieter, more refined, and slightly more distinctive. It is especially compelling for someone looking to diversify the leather options in their wardrobe.
Both integrate easily into a refined wardrobe and feel wearable year-round. Rather than competing, they offer two distinct expressions of the same silhouette: one softer and easier, the other quieter and more elevated.
Explore More Row Guides
Agnes 12 Review - an in-depth look at the silhouette
Polished vs Matte Grained Leather — how The Row’s calfskin finishes differ
Margaux Size Guide — how each size carries in daily use
Margaux 10 vs Shoulder 12 — a detailed comparison of the smaller Margaux silhouettes
Marlo vs Peggy — comparing two everyday alternative silhouettes to the Margaux
Park Tote Size Guide — how each size carries in daily use
This site contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission on qualifying purchases. All recommendations are editorially independent.